ABSTRACT
Nicotine addiction and dependence is a chronic relapsing disease driven by addiction to nicotine. Proactive treatment for all tobacco users, regardless of their readiness to quit, is recommended. First-line tobacco cessation medications include nicotine replacement therapy, bupropion, and varenicline. Comprehensive treatment with behavioral interventions and pharmacologic therapy increases success rates of smoking cessation. Although there are many popular alternative treatments, they should not replace or delay the use of known effective therapies.
An individualized treatment for tobacco cessation is necessary and should be based on severity of nicotine dependence, probability of developing withdrawal symptoms, comorbidities, local resources, and patient preferences.
Comprehensive smoking cessation treatment provides counseling, assesses the patient’s readiness to quit, offers treatment options, and arranges follow-up.
Evidence is lacking to support the use of smart phone “apps” for smoking cessation as monotherapy.
E-cigarettes are not used in tobacco cessation treatment as they can also cause nicotine addiction and other concerns.
Tobacco use continues to be a major public health problem and a major risk factor for deaths from heart disease and several types of cancer such as lung, head and neck, and colorectal cancers.1 The prevalence of smoking has declined over the last 6 decades, to an all-time low of 13.7% in adults in 2018.2 However, nicotine dependence is still considered a common and significant clinical problem.
A number of effective therapies exist, yet treating patients for tobacco cessation remains a challenge, not only for patients, but also for clinicians, who may not be aware of effective therapies available and may fail to offer treatment. Therefore, it is important for clinicians to familiarize themselves with treatment options they can offer to every smoker.
In this article, we review behavioral interventions and pharmacotherapy to treat nicotine dependence associated with tobacco use. We also discuss the role of e-cigarettes.
A PROACTIVE APPROACH TO TOBACCO CESSATION
The 2008 US Public Health Service guidelines outlined an evidence-based behavioral intervention to manage tobacco treatment in primary care called the 5-A (ask, advise, assess, assist, and arrange) framework, which is still used today.3 Its aim is to identify every smoker, provide counseling, assess readiness to quit, offer treatment options, and arrange follow-up.
Nicotine dependence is a chronic, relapsing disease driven by addiction to nicotine. A proactive approach is needed, offering treatment to all smokers regardless of their level of readiness to quit. Treatment should be individualized based on the severity of nicotine dependence and the probability of developing withdrawal symptoms, as well as on comorbidities, local resources, and patient preferences.3
Pharmacotherapy for tobacco treatment is based on alleviating symptoms of nicotine withdrawal with nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) and on optimal use of medications such as varenicline and bupropion. The best results are obtained when pharmacotherapy is combined with behavioral interventions.3
EVALUATION OF NICOTINE DEPENDENCE
The severity of nicotine dependence, risk of developing withdrawal symptoms, and risk of relapse should be determined. The Heaviness of Smoking Index is a simple and validated test to assess the strength of a smoker’s nicotine dependence. It consists of 2 questions, making it a quick and practical tool to administer (Table 1).4 Other indicators of nicotine dependence include early initiation of tobacco use, difficulty attaining prolonged abstinence from smoking, history of withdrawal symptoms, and continued use despite knowledge of harm.
The Heaviness of Smoking Index
Nondaily smokers may use cigarettes compulsively in certain situations but may not have withdrawal symptoms. Factors that influence the risk of relapse include the degree of motivation to quit, presence of comorbid psychiatric disorders, other substance use (eg, heavy alcohol use), and living with other smokers. Nondaily smokers should be advised to quit smoking completely and should be offered assistance to do so. The need for pharmacotherapy should be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.
On the other hand, daily smokers with high nicotine dependence benefit from combination therapies including pharmacotherapy and behavioral interventions.
BEHAVIORAL INTERVENTIONS
Behavioral support can be provided in face-to-face meetings, group sessions, and text messages. It is typically provided by specialists in tobacco cessation counseling. Interventions that combine pharmacotherapy and behavioral support increase tobacco cessation rates compared with minimal intervention or usual care.5,6 Intensive support, especially when it involves in-person contact, increases the chance of abstinence by about 10% to 20%.7
Advice and counseling
Providing advice about quitting is the most common form of behavioral intervention. Even a brief verbal exchange can increase cessation rates.8 Ideally, the advice should be tailored to individual circumstances.
Self-help materials with additional advice and information may also be beneficial. Standardized, print-based, self-help materials increase quit rates compared with no intervention.9 However, individual counseling is more effective than self-help materials in promoting smoking cessation, and a more intensive counseling intervention is more effective than a less intensive intervention.10 Table 2 lists messages that can be used when giving advice to quit.
Suggested messages to use when giving advice on tobacco cessation
Motivational interviewing
Motivational interviewing is a more intense form of behavioral intervention,11 though less commonly used due to lack of knowledge or training. The aims are to increase motivation in smokers who do not intend to quit, to enhance self-control over smoking behavior, and to assist in structuring a plan and techniques to control urges and cues.
Motivational interviewing is a collaborative, patient-focused counseling technique. It is designed to help people to explore and resolve ambivalence about behavior change.11
Group therapy or classes
Group therapy or classes offer individuals the opportunity to learn behavioral techniques and provide them with mutual support.12
FIRST-LINE THERAPEUTICS
Nicotine replacement therapy
NRT delivers nicotine in place of smoking or tobacco use to reduce the urge to smoke, as well as associated withdrawal symptoms.13
Clinical guidelines recommend NRT as a first-line treatment for tobacco cessation.14 All commercially available forms (gum, transdermal patch, nasal spray, inhaler, and lozenges) are effective in helping smokers increase their chance of quitting successfully.15 Each product has about the same efficacy, increasing quit rates by 50% to 70% compared with placebo. However, NRT is most effective when the nicotine patch is used in conjunction with a more rapidly absorbed form of NRT (eg, gum).15
In the United States, nicotine replacement products are available over the counter or by prescription (Table 3). The initial dosing of most products is based on the number of cigarettes smoked daily or on the time to the first cigarette after waking.
First-line pharmacologic options for tobacco cessation
Nicotine patches deliver nicotine in a sustained manner throughout the day.16 More rapidly absorbed forms of NRT such as gum, lozenges, inhalers, and spray relieve withdrawal symptoms more quickly than patches. None of the available nicotine delivery systems reproduces the rapid and high levels of arterial nicotine achieved when cigarette smoke is inhaled.16 This partially explains why nicotine replacement does not completely eliminate the symptoms of withdrawal. A rapid-release of nicotine gum has been formulated and may achieve faster withdrawal relief.17,18
In general, NRT is recommended for 2 to 3 months after smoking cessation. However, it may be used through the period when patients are at high risk for relapse. Some smokers may need to use nicotine replacement products indefinitely. There is no evidence to show that gradual withdrawal of NRT is better than abrupt withdrawal.
Side effects of nicotine replacement products include nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, diarrhea, headache, and local irritation depending on the delivery method.13 These can be managed by titrating or changing products. Long-term use is not associated with any serious harmful effects, and the risk of dependence on nicotine replacement products is small.13
Bupropion
Bupropion is an antidepressant. Its mechanism of action in the treatment of nicotine dependence is not well understood.19 The main hypothesized effect is the attenuation of withdrawal symptoms (eg, irritability, anxiety) by mimicking nicotinic effects on dopamine and noradrenaline receptors.20
Sustained-release bupropion is an effective aid to help smokers quit with or without depression.21 It is effective as monotherapy and comparable to the nicotine patch in efficacy.3,22 However, the combination of bupropion with NRT is more effective than bupropion or NRT alone.23
Bupropion is typically started 1 to 2 weeks before a patient’s planned quit date, at a dose of 150 mg daily. After 3 days, the dose should be increased to 150 mg twice daily for 7 to 12 weeks. After this period, bupropion can be continued for up to 12 months, as long as abstinence is attained (maintenance dosage 300 mg/day).14
Common side effects are insomnia (decreased if medication given at least 8 hours before bedtime), headache, dizziness, diaphoresis, weight loss, xerostomia, nausea and vomiting, and pharyngitis.24 There is no increase in the incidence of neuropsychiatric adverse events with bupropion compared with placebo in psychiatric and nonpsychiatric cohorts.21
Bupropion is contraindicated in patients with seizure disorder and high-risk conditions such as brain arteriovenous malformation, severe head injury, severe stroke, and central nervous tumor or infection. Other contraindications include the presence of anorexia or bulimia; abrupt discontinuation of ethanol; current use of benzodiazepines, barbiturates, or antiepileptic drugs; use of monoamine oxidase inhibitors in the previous 2 weeks; and as concomitant use of linezolid or intravenous methylene blue, a reversible monoamine oxidase inhibitor.
Varenicline
Varenicline is a partial agonist on 2 nicotinic acetylcholine receptors.25,26 These receptors mediate the release of dopamine, the main neurotransmitter underlying nicotine addiction. The partial agonist action decreases the intensity of withdrawal symptoms. It also reduces nicotine binding to nicotinic acetylcholine receptors that generates rewarding effects, thus reducing the perceived pleasure generated by nicotine consumption. This explains why patients on this medication reduce their cigarette consumption even before their quit date.14
Although it is recommended to start varenicline dosing at least 1 to 2 weeks before the target quit date (the “fixed target quit date” approach), other approaches are acceptable:
Medication preloading: ie, starting pharmacotherapy while the smoker is still smoking
Flexible quit date: patient chooses a quit date within 1 month of starting medication
Reduce-to-quit approach: gradual smoking reduction with the goal of eventually quitting completely.27
Dosing titration starts with 0.5 mg orally once daily for 3 days, with up-titration every 3 days to 1 mg orally twice daily until the end of treatment. In patients who develop adverse effects, lower doses of varenicline (eg, 0.5 mg twice daily) can be used. If well tolerated, varenicline may be used up to 6 months for continued abstinence.28
Efficacy. Varenicline is effective in helping smokers achieve tobacco abstinence. It is superior to placebo, bupropion, and NRT.29 Clinical guidelines recommend varenicline as first-line treatment in conjunction with behavioral therapy for a minimum of 12 weeks.3,14,30 It may be used in combination with NRT to achieve higher rates of abstinence.31
The additive efficacy of combining varenicline and NRT may be due to the partial agonism of individual drugs leading to synergistic effects when combined, or to NRT binding to different or additional receptors not stimulated by varenicline. It is also possible that short-acting nicotine replacement products add to the effect by allowing as-needed dosing and relief of withdrawal symptoms.32
Contraindications are a history of severe hypersensitivity reactions and skin reactions to varenicline. Seizure disorder is not a contraindication, though occurrence of seizures during therapy warrants medication cessation.
Common side effects of varenicline use are nausea, insomnia, abnormal dreams, headache, nasopharyngitis, and xerostomia.21
Postmarketing reports of neuropsychiatric adverse effects have included suicidal ideation and behavior, completed suicide, changes in mood, psychosis, aggression, and hostility; these have been reported in smokers with and without previous psychiatric conditions, prompting drug label warnings in many countries.33,34 Observational studies, randomized clinical trials, and meta-analyses have not confirmed these concerns, leading the US Food and Drug Administration to remove the boxed warning in 2015 for both varenicline and bupropion.34,35
In summary, varenicline does not increase the risk of depression, suicidal ideation, or cardiovascular disease.36,37
SECOND-LINE THERAPEUTICS
Nortriptyline and clonidine are second-line pharmacotherapies. Nortriptyline is a tricyclic antidepressant that has a beneficial effect in smoking cessation.38 As with bupropion, its effect on smoking cessation is unrelated to its antidepressant activity. It should be used carefully in patients with chronic heart disease due to potential for QT-segment prolongation.19,38
Clonidine is a selective alpha-adrenergic receptor agonist used to treat hypertension. It has been used off-label to treat withdrawal symptoms due to its effect in the central nervous system. It is effective for smoking cessation when compared with placebo, but side effects such as dry mouth and sedation limit its use.19,39
It is not clear whether one second-line therapy is more effective than the other. Second-line therapies can be considered when first-line treatments fail or are contraindicated.
DRUG INTERACTIONS
When prescribing a tobacco cessation drug, it is important to consider the potential for drug interactions (Table 4).24,40,41
Drug interactions to consider in tobacco cessation treatment
Nicotine
Nicotine from NRT is generally absorbed more slowly and gradually than nicotine from cigarettes, leading to lower nicotine blood levels.42 Nicotine may cause tachycardia regardless of the source, so it is possible that nicotine could enhance the tachycardic effect of certain drugs with similar effects on heart rate, such as adenosine.43 Drugs that inhibit cytochrome P450 enzymes (eg, cimetidine), which participate in nicotine metabolism, could decrease the clearance of nicotine, thereby increasing the physiologic effects of nicotine.44
Varenicline
Because varenicline is a substrate of the kidney transport protein organic cation transporter 2 (OCT2), medications that inhibit OCT2 could increase the serum concentration of varenicline and therefore increase the risk for adverse effects, especially in patients with renal disease.24
Neuropsychiatric adverse effects such as aggressive behavior and amnesia have been reported with the combination of alcohol and varenicline.33 Because varenicline may increase the intoxicating effect of alcohol, patients should be counseled to reduce their alcohol intake while on varenicline until they know how varenicline affects their alcohol tolerance.33
Bupropion
Bupropion should not be prescribed for tobacco cessation in patients taking drugs that lower the seizure threshold. The combination may enhance neuroexcitatory effects, thereby increasing the risk of seizures.40 Alcohol should be used with caution in patients taking bupropion: it not only lowers the seizure threshold, but also may reduce alcohol tolerance. Patients should be advised to minimize or avoid alcohol consumption while taking bupropion.40
Bupropion is a strong inhibitor of the enzyme cytochrome P450 2D6 (CYP2D6), which increases the concentration of drugs that are CYP2D6 substrates and the risk for adverse effects for many of these agents.43 However, certain CYP2D6 substrates such as codeine, tramadol, hydrocodone, and tamoxifen rely on CYP2D6 for the metabolic conversion of these drugs to their active metabolites.45,46 Concurrent use of bupropion may lead to an inadequate therapeutic response to these agents that are activated by CYP2D6.
Bupropion is contraindicated in patients taking monoamine oxidase inhibitors, which can enhance the hypertensive effect of bupropion. These drugs should not be used concomitantly or within 14 days of one another.47
Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors. Reports suggest that concurrent use of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors with bupropion may increase the risk for serious toxicity such as serotonin syndrome; however, the mechanism is unclear because the antidepressant effects of bupropion are largely dopamine-based, with less-pronounced effects on serotonin activity.48 Antiparkinson agents may enhance the adverse effects of bupropion through cumulative dopamine agonist effects.
Patients taking bupropion for tobacco cessation who are currently taking other dopaminergic agents should be monitored for evidence of central nervous system toxicities such as restlessness, agitation, tremor, ataxia, gait disturbance, vertigo, and dizziness.40
Digoxin. Bupropion may decrease the serum concentration of digoxin. Thus, digoxin levels should be monitored if these drugs are used concomitantly.
Finally, drugs that inhibit or induce CYP2B6, the major enzyme involved in the metabolism of bupropion, can interact with bupropion by increasing or decreasing its concentration, respectively.24
Effects on drug metabolism after quitting
In addition to considering the potential drug interactions between a selected smoking cessation product and a patient’s current medications, it is also important to note that successful smoking cessation can alter the metabolism of medications once the effects of cigarette smoke are eliminated.
Tobacco smoke is known to induce cytochrome P450 enzymes, particularly CYP1A2. Therefore, smokers more rapidly metabolize certain medications that are substrates of this enzyme.41,49 When tobacco use ceases, the concentration of these drugs can increase, raising the potential for adverse drug events.
Clozapine, olanzapine, and theophylline may cause clinically significant adverse effects upon smoking cessation, including seizures with clozapine, extrapyramidal effects with olanzapine, and tachycardia with theophylline.49,50 Thus, it is important to closely monitor patients taking these drugs when they quit smoking and adjust the dosage.
OTHER INTERVENTIONS
Smart phone app-based interventions
The widespread use of smart phones and the advent of health-related apps have the potential to make smoking cessation interventions more accessible. Smart phone apps offer the opportunity to provide tailored behavioral support and real-time responses to smoking urges and cues.51 They may help adolescents and young adults adhere to treatment. However, there are concerns regarding their quality and effectiveness,52,53 as most apps do not follow existing smoking-cessation treatment guidelines, and the quality of the content is variable.51,53,54
While apps could be a successful strategy for specific patients, evidence is lacking to support their use as monotherapy, and they should not replace interventions known to be effective. More research and innovation are needed to evaluate the role and efficacy of mobile apps as a smoking cessation intervention.
Alternative interventions
Hypnotherapy is widely promoted as a method for aiding smoking cessation. However, there is currently insufficient evidence to determine whether hypnotherapy is effective.55 Electro-stimulation is not effective for smoking cessation.56
Acupuncture is promoted as a treatment for smoking cessation that can control withdrawal symptoms.56 Acupuncture combined with counseling and an educational smoking cessation program may be beneficial.57 However, there is very limited high-quality evidence to support acupuncture as monotherapy in smoking cessation.56 Well-designed research into these alternative therapies is necessary, especially since these are popular interventions.
OPPORTUNITIES TO ENCOURAGE TOBACCO CESSATION
Pregnancy
Female patients of childbearing age and pregnant patients represent an opportunity for clinicians to encourage smoking cessation. All pregnant patients should be counseled to quit. Patients should be counseled about the adverse effects of tobacco use and about effects such as subfertility and miscarriage risks.58,59
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists recommends that NRT be considered for pregnant women with a strong resolution to quit. Bupropion is also a reasonable first-line therapy.60 However, there is limited evidence supporting the subsequent addition of bupropion in patients as a first-line treatment in female patients unable to tolerate NRT or as an addition to counseling and NRT. Varenicline is typically not used in this setting due to the limited data supporting its safety.60
Inpatients
Hospital admission requires temporary tobacco abstinence, providing an opportunity to initiate treatment. The primary reason for hospitalization may serve as an opportunity to provide personalized advice and motivation to quit, especially if surgery is undertaken during the same admission.61
Smokers are far more likely to quit if they are provided close follow-up after inpatient discharge (eg, during follow-up appointments) vs traditional provision of postdischarge pharmacotherapy and recommendations alone.62
Cardiovascular disease
The increased risk of cardiovascular disease from tobacco use is well known. In patients with known atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, the approach to tobacco cessation is the same as for patients without cardiovascular disease. Data show that NRT, bupropion, and varenicline do not significantly increase the risk of adverse cardiovascular events.63
The lack of evidence regarding the efficacy and safety of NRT in acute coronary syndrome and the theoretical concern for nicotine’s vasoconstrictive properties may explain why clinicians tend to avoid recommending it. However, NRT is a first-line therapy for the relief of withdrawal symptoms in inpatients with acute coronary syndrome, according to expert consensus.14 NRT or varenicline can be prescribed at hospital discharge.14
Preoperative evaluation
Because cigarette smoking increases the risk for poor postoperative outcomes, formal preoperative counseling and use of NRT are recommended because they result in greater rates of preoperative cessation and lower rates of postoperative complications than no treatment.64
Concerns that quitting shortly before surgery could increase the risk of pulmonary complications have been found to be unsubstantiated.65 Patients should be advised to quit at any time before surgery. Although the optimal duration of abstinence is not known, a greater reduction in risk of complications is associated with longer periods of abstinence.66 As with hospitalized patients undergoing surgical procedures, postdischarge cessation rates were found to be highest in those who received formal perioperative counseling and pharmacotherapy.67
Psychiatric and mental health considerations
Nicotine dependence is known to exacerbate concurrent mental illnesses and psychiatric disorders. However, patients with psychiatric needs are less likely to be provided with tobacco cessation counseling or pharmacotherapy.68 Recent studies have shown that the safety of NRT, varenicline, and bupropion are comparable between patients with and without psychiatric disorders.21 It is reasonable to offer varenicline and NRT alongside formal tobacco cessation counseling, followed by use of bupropion as a second-line agent in the ab sence of a documented seizure history.69
ELECTRONIC CIGARETTES
E-cigarettes have been proposed as a method to reduce the harms of tobacco use and as a nicotine replacement product.70 However, e-cigarettes can also cause nicotine dependence, so users may need treatment for nicotine dependence similar to that for tobacco users.71
Studies in tobacco cessation
E-cigarettes have been promoted as safe alternatives to combustible cigarettes, and they have been studied in randomized controlled trials as a treatment for tobacco cessation.72
One randomized trial compared nicotine-containing e-cigarettes with NRT.72 The e-cigarette group abstinence rate was 18% at 12 months, though 80% continued use of e-cigarettes, compared with a 9% abstinence rate in the NRT group and a 9% rate of continued use of NRT.72
Although e-cigarettes were beneficial in achieving abstinence, the concern is that individuals continued to use them. It is not clear whether e-cigarettes truly reduce harm as they are not as safe as they are promoted to be. While nicotine inhalation with e-cigarettes is thought to release fewer toxic by-products than combustible cigarettes, there are concerns regarding their safety.73 Carcinogens and toxins have been found in the liquid used for vaporization and in the aerosols emitted, and e-cigarettes have been associated with an outbreak of cases of acute lung injury that caused hospitalizations and even deaths.74,75
The long-term consequences are unknown, but several studies have shown the potential of e-cigarettes to cause chronic lung and heart disease and to increase the risk of infection and of cancer.76
The potential for nicotine addiction with e-cigarettes is also concerning. Pod systems (eg, JUUL brand) are popular devices that can deliver high concentrations of nicotine through the use of nicotine salts.77,78 For example, each JUUL pod may contain a nicotine concentration of 3% (equivalent to 35 mg/mL) or 5% (equivalent to 59 mg/mL).79 A combustible cigarette has a nicotine concentration between 1.5% and 2%.80 It is worrisome that e-cigarette users are often unaware of or underestimate the nicotine content.81,82
Managing nicotine dependence related to e-cigarettes
It is not clear whether nicotine dependence from e-cigarette use should be managed differently than that from combustible cigarette smoking. Because the addiction is to the same substance, it is likely that the same strategies and tools could be applied with careful attention to the unique aspects of e-cigarette use.
The pattern of use with e-cigarettes is different. An e-cigarette does not need to be lit; it can be used any time and with a potentially higher frequency than combustible cigarettes; and nicotine concentrations can be higher in e-cigarettes. Thus, this pattern of use can pose a higher risk of withdrawal symptoms.
This highlights the need for clinicians to familiarize themselves with different e-cigarette products and their nicotine content, as well as the need for further investigation into whether higher doses of NRT are necessary in these patients.
E-cigarettes use by adolescents: A public health concern
Another important aspect is the high prevalence of e-cigarette use among adolescents. Adolescent e-cigarette usage is now a major public health concern, with 1 in every 6 high school students reporting current e-cigarette use.83,84
Treatment options for adolescents are more limited than those for adults. Neither varenicline nor bupropion has shown benefit in the adolescent population based on limited studies of nicotine dependence associated with combustible cigarettes.85 NRT combined with cognitive-behavioral interventions has been shown to be effective in adolescent cigarette smokers.86 However, further research is needed to determine the most effective treatment of nicotine dependence in adolescents, especially when it is associated with e-cigarette use.
THE BOTTOM LINE
Nicotine dependence is a chronic relapsing disease. Every tobacco user should be offered treatment for tobacco cessation regardless of their level of readiness to quit.
Treatment should be based on the severity of nicotine dependence, the probability of developing withdrawal symptoms, risk of relapse, comorbidities, local resources, and patient preferences.
Comprehensive tobacco treatment that combines pharmacologic and behavioral therapy significantly increases successful tobacco cessation. Although there are many popular alternative treatments, they should not replace or delay the use of known effective therapies.
E-cigarettes have been proposed as a method of reducing the harms of tobacco use, but they also can cause nicotine addiction. Moreover, their effectiveness in tobacco cessation treatment has not been determined, and concerns related to their safety preclude their use in tobacco cessation treatment at this time.
DISCLOSURES
The authors report no relevant financial relationships which, in the context of their contributions, could be perceived as a potential conflict of interest.
- Copyright © 2021 The Cleveland Clinic Foundation. All Rights Reserved.